Manual on Methods of Reproducing Research Materials
A Survey Made for the Joint Committee on Materials for Research of the Social Science Research Council and the American Council of Learned Societies
1936

Edited by Peter Binkley; licensed under CC BY 4.0
Source code: github.com/pbinkley/rcb-manual

Word count: 2200

p.front p.front pastedown p.front flyleaf a \(blank\) p.front flyleaf b \(blank\) p.[i] MANUAL ON METHODS
OF
REPRODUCING RESEARCH
MATERIALS

A Survey made for the Joint Committee on Materials for
Research of the Social Science Research Council and
the American Council of Learned Societies

By

ROBERT C. BINKLEY
Western Reserve University
Cleveland, Ohio

WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF
Dr. T. R. SCHELLENBERG, Professor Miles HANLEY
Miss Josephine McCarter, Miss Adeline Barry
AND Many Others

EDWARDS BROTHERS LN GC,
ANN ARBOR, MICHIGAN

1936

p.[ii] Copyright 1936, by
The Joint Committee on Materials for Research

Printed IN U.S.A.
Lithoprinted by Edwards Brothers, Inc., Lithoprinters and Publishers
Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1936

p.iii

FOREWORD

The Joint Committee on Materials for Research had its inception in action taken by the Social Science Research Council at its Hanover conference in August, 1929. At this conference the Council approved a tentative definition of its objective which included the enlargement, improvement, and preservation of materials.” This was elaborated as follows:

“Since scientific progress in all fields is conditioned by the existence of a constantly enlarging body of research materials and by its availability to investigators, one of the primary duties of the Council is to promote such objects and to concern itself with the improvement and preservation of research data. In carrying out these purposes the following courses of action are appropriate:

A. Initiating and participating in plans for making more comparable and more widely serviceable the classifications of social and economic data, for making more precise the significance of the data, and for otherwise improving such records.

B. Helping to lay out a plan for the nation-wide development and coördination of existing archival collections and for the building up of new research collections along special lines at strategic scholarly and geographical centers.

C. Initiating and participating in plans for constructing union finding lists and calendars of the resources of existing research libraries, with particular reference to their social data, so as to make them more available to scholars.

D. Initiating and participating in plans to discover, select, edit, publish, or otherwise reproduce basic data in the social sciences, which are difficult of access to students or likely to perish.

E. Calling to the attention of individuals and of governmental, business, and other institutions and agencies the importance of preserving their records for future analysis and study.

F. Encouraging the adoption and widespread use of those varieties of paper and other materials used in the making of records which promise a maximum durability.

G. Initiating, encouraging, and participating in plans to develop the research uses of historical, industrial, and social museums; and encouraging the building up of new collections with these purposes in mind.”

The American Council of Learned Societies, which is interested primarily in the humanities, including history, had concerned itself for some years with materials for research; and, as the problems of the two Councils in this field are much the same and often involve the same material, it was logical for them to join in setting up a joint committee on materials for research. This committee, after a number of changes in personnel, consists at present of the following members:

p.iv

  • Robert C. Binkley, Western Reserve University, Chairman
  • T. R. Schellenberg, National Archives, Secretary
  • Laurence V. Coleman, American Association of Museums
  • Norman S. B. Gras, Harvard University
  • H. M. Lydenberg, New York Public Library
  • Arthur H. Quinn, University of Pennsylvania
  • Verne E. Chatelain, National Park Service

In the course of its first two meetings in 1930, the committee set on foot three surveys. A “Survey of Activities of American Agencies in Relation to Materials for Research in the Social Sciences and Humanities” was compiled by Franklin F. Holbrook, under the direction of Professor Solon J. Buck, and published in a small edition in the spring of 1932. A study of the categories of research material which ought to be collected and preserved was undertaken by a subcommittee headed by Professor Gras. The task of making a survey of methods of reproducing research materials was assigned to Robert C. Binkley, then secretary of the committee. A tentative edition of this survey was issued in December, 1931, and circulated for corrections and additions, which have been incorporated in the present edition.

p.v

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The collaboration of scholars, technicians, and business men in the preparation of this manual has been generous and long- continued. The list of names carried in the index is in itself a list of helpful collaborators to whom acknowledgment is due. If the list were to be extended to all who have given sympathetic aid, it would cover pages.

The correspondence covering the matters brought together in this book has been carried on for six years. The conclusions here set forth have been slowly crystallized in the presence of constantly changing cost levels and constantly improved mechanical equipment. Much of the book that deals with tabulations of cost and with descriptions of equipment will undoubtedly be outdated in the near future; some of it is perhaps already out of date at the moment of going to press.

It is hoped, however, that the basic thought of the book will still stand: namely, that the great variety of devices which modern technology offers to modern scholarship should be kept under constant scrutiny, both from the standpoint of utility and of comparative cost.

Robert C. Binkley

Western Reserve University
April 14, 1936

p.[vi] p.vii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Chapter Page
Front matter front
I The Setting of the Problem of Reproducing Research Materials 1
II Publishing and Library Costs: The Book 3
III Printed Books and Reprints 13
IV The Typescript Book or Memorandum: The Typewriter and Typescript 31
V The Typescript Book or Memorandum: Reproduction Techniques 41
VI Blueprinting, Photostating, and Allied Techniques 65
VII Books Containing Characters Not in the Roman Alphabet, Tabular Matter, Diagrams and Illustrations 81
VIII A Study of Paper Permanence 95
IX Binding, Vertical Filing, and Film Storage 111
X Reduced-Scale Photographic and Photolithographing Copying on Paper for Reading Through Magnifying Glasses 115
XI Cost Levels and Applications of Microcopying and Projection Reading 121
XII Photographic and Projecting Apparatus 161
XIII The Recording of Sound 177
XIV Conclusion 183
Index 203

p.xi

LIST OF TABLES

Table Page
I Costs in Commercial and Scholarly Publishing 4
II Costs and Returns from a Typical Research Book 7
III Acquisition Sums Spent by Forty of the Larger University and College Libraries 8
IV Estimates for Printing by Mimeoform and Straight Printing a Book of 50,000 Words 20
V Estimates for Printing by Mimeoform and Straight Printing a Book of 50,000 Words in Economy Format 20
VI Prices on Photo-Offset Printing Surface 23
VII Cost of Printing Surface for Dermaprint, Rotaprint, and Multilith Work 28
VIII Prices of Dermaprint Service 29
IX Comparison of Factors Affecting Book Manufacturing Costs 30
X Types of Varityper Machines 34
XI High Variation in Typescript Composition Costs per 1,000 Words 39
XII Number of Carbon Copies Possible with One Typing 41
XIII Variation of Normal Cost of Labor and Materials in Composition Costs in Carbon Copying 42
XIV Cost of Carbon Copy Books of 100,000 Words 42
XV Cost of Liquid Process Hectograph Books of 100,000 Words 45
XVI Prices of Mimeograph Stencils 47
XVII Prices of Metal Sheets for Direct Typing 48
XVIII Costs of Printing Surfaces for Direct Typing 48
XIX Formats for Accommodating Various Number of Words per Page 50
XX Mimeograph Costs for Producing 100,000 Words in Variety of Formats 51
XXI Comparison of Office and Shop Charges for Mimeographing Book of 100,000 Words 52
XXII Cost of Reproducing 100,000 Words by "Mimeograph" Processes 52
XXIII Composition Costs of Format Copy of Book under Varying Conditions of Cost Distribution 57
XXIV Photo-Offset Prices 61
XXV Chart of Blueprint Dimensions 69
XXVI Price per Square Foot of Blueprint and Allied Processes 70
XXVII Costs of Photostat Paper to Produce 100-Page Book in Different Page Sizes 72
XXVIII Chart of Photostat Prices 74
XXIX Comparative Costs of Typescript, Photostat, Blueprint, and Photo-Offset 78
XXX Key Figures of Unit Costs of Reproduction 79
XXXI Cost of 100-Page Octavo Book Containing All Pictorial Matter 91
XXXII Costs of Reproducing Book of Pictorial Matter in Varying Page and Picture Sizes 92
XXXIII Analysis of Production Costs of Illustrations Combined with Text 94
XXXIV Classification of Book Papers 99
XXXV Book Papers and Proposed Permanence of Classifications 102
XXXVa Chart of Paper Specifications 110
XXXVI Cost of a Good Library Binding for a Book 1 1/2&quot
XXXVII Thresholds of Legibility in Reductions of Typescript and Newsprint 116
XXXVIII Reduction Ratio and Legibility of Projected Image of 7-Point Newsprint Photographed in Different Kinds of Microcopying Cameras 123
XXXIX Price per Square Foot of Usable Surface 126
XL Comparative Prices of Photographic Surface on Paper, Glass, and Film; with Reduction Ratios to Bring Prices to Common Levels 127
XLI Film Footages Required in Copying Books in Different Positions on 35mm. Film and 16mm. Film, Using Full Width of Film 129
XLII Prices of Film Processing 129
XLIII Effect of Variation in Processing Costs on Price of Microcopy Positive of a Book of 100 Pages, 6" x 9", in Varying Reduction Ratios 130
XLIV Graph Showing Amount of Microcopying Necessary to Justify Expenditure of Any Given Increment in Price of Reading Machine Equipment 142
XLV Chart of Apertures and Correspondence to Frame of Film 148
XLVI Costs of Acquiring or Maintaining One Year of a Newspaper File of Approximately 18,000 Pages per Year 156
XLVII Chart Showing Chief Characteristics of Copying Cameras 163
XLVIII Chart Giving Chief Characteristics of Projectors 176
XLIX Running Costs Stated as Percentages of First Cost 184
L Efficiency Point in Edition for Various Processes 185
LI Edition Size at Which 90% of Unit Cost is Running Cost and 10% is First Cost 185
LII Efficiency Costs for Three Processes 186
LIII Costs per Thousand Words at Efficiency Point 187
LIV Edition Size at Which Cost of Production is Approximately $1.50 per 100,000 Words: 188
LV Unit Costs for Reproducing 100,000 Words in a Variety of Processes in Editions of 1 to 100 190

p.xiii

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS

Figure Facing Page
I Example of Century Expanded and of Granjon Type 15
II An Economical Print-Face Format 15
III An Economical Print-Face Format 15
IV Example of 8- and 10-point Bodoni Type 17
V Model 100 Multigraph 18
VI Page of Mimeoform Work 19
VII An Economical Mimeoform Format 19
VIII Sample Piece of Multilith Metal Sheet 21
IX Sample Piece of Rotaprint Metal Sheet 21
X The Rotaprint 21
XI Model 200 Multilith 21
XII Harris Press 22
XIII Curve of Diminishing Legibility 25
XIV Page Of Dermaprint Work 27
XV Comparison of Print and Reduced Typescript of Same Legibility 32
XVI Page Demonstrating Spielvogel Aligning Paper 33
XVII Sample of Varityper Work Reduced by Photo-Offset 33
XVIII Sample of Varityper Work Done on Mimeograph 34
XIX Page of Photo-Offset Work Done on Different Machines 37
XX The Ormig Duplicator 43
XXI The Standard New Process Duplicator 43
XXII Sample of Hectograph Gelatin Work 45
XXIIIa Samples of Hectograph Liquid Work (Standard New Process) 45
XXIIIb 45
XXIV Sample of Hectograph Liquid Work (Ormig) 45
XXV Sample of Rotaprint Direct Typing Work 49
XXVI Sample of Multilith Direct Typing Work 49
XXVII Sample of Mimeograph Work on Wax Stencil 49
XXVIII Sample of Micro-Elite Mimeograph Work 49
XXIX Comparison of Print and Reduced Typescript with Same Word Content 53
XXX An Economical Photo-Offset Format 55
XXXI An Inexpensive Photo-Offset Format 58
XXXII An Inexpensive Photo-Offset Format 58
XXXIII An Expensive Photo-Offset Format 59
XXXIV A Typical Photo-Offset Format 59
XXXV A Typical Photo-Offset Format 59
XXXVI A Manuscript Page Reproduced by Photo-Offset 63
XXXVIIa Example of B-W Work 67
XXXVIIb Example of Blue Line Print from Paper Negative 67
XXXVIII The Photostat 73
XXXIX The Rectigraph 73
XL The Dexigraph 76
XLI Screened Picture Run on Harris Press 86
XLII Screened Picture Run on Rotaprint Press 87
XLIII Screened Picture Run on Multilith Press 87
XLIV Sample of Collotype Work 88
XLV Sample of Collotype Work 88
XLVI Sample of 80-Line Zinc Cut 88
XLVII Sample of 133-Line Coppers Cut 88
XLVIII Sample of 80-Line Zinc Cut 88
XLIX Sample of 133-Line Copper Cut 88
L Page of Aquatone Work 89
LI Example of Photo-Offset Half-tone Work 91
LII Example of Photo-Offset Half-tone Work 91
LIII Sample of Newspaper Preservation 105
LIV Quarter-Size Page of New York *Times* 115
LV Photo-Offset Reproduction of Abstract Page Done by Peters' Method 116
LVI Fiskoscope 117
LVII Fiske Reading Strip 117
LVIII Spencer Magnifier 118
LIX Bendikson's Microprints 118
LX Bendikson's Microscope 118
LXI Van Iterson's Device 119
LXII Examples of Photo-Offset and Typescript Reduced and Enlarged 124
LXIIa 124
LXIIb 124
LXIIc 124
LXIIIa Collotype Reproduction of Dagron Film 124
LXIV Sample of 16mm. Film 126
LXV Sample of 35mm. Film 126
LXVI Leica Camera, Projector, and Accessory Lenses 165
LXVII Draeger Camera (Early Model) 170
LXVIII New Folmer Graflex Camera 170
LXIX Recordak Copying Camera 172
LXX Recordak Projector 172
LXXI Teledex Projector 174
LXXII Spencer Projector 174
LXXIII Professor Hanley's Phonographic Equipment 180